When it comes to choosing the best sleep tracker for your needs, there are a few things to consider. First, you’ll want to think about whether you want a device that you wear on your wrist or one that fits under your mattress. There are pros and cons to each type of device, and the best choice for you will depend on your personal preferences and needs. In this article, we’ll provide an overview of the different types of sleep trackers available on the market and give you our recommendations for the best sleep-tracking devices in 2023. We’ll also share our experience testing these devices and provide tips on how to get the most out of your sleep tracker. And while we’re on the topic of quality sleep, don’t forget to check out our ultimate guide to choosing a mattress.
Best sleep trackers 2023
It’s worth noting that the Bose SleepBuds II are a viable option for listening to music in bed, but without dedicated sleep tracking functionality, they don’t technically qualify for our chart.
No need to wear anything Discreet sleep tracking Sleep Apnoea detection
No smart features One tracker per person
The simple grey mat slides under your mattress and tracks sleep quality and duration along with snoring, heart rate, and sleep apnoea, giving you a fairly comprehensive overview of your sleeping patterns. With nothing to wear and no battery to worry about, the Sleep Analyzer gets out of your way – but as you’ll need one tracker per person, you’ll need to be pretty invested in getting a good night’s rest.
Monitors 'breathing disturbances' Detailed sleep tracking Traditional wristwatch design
Expensive Limited smart features
The watch includes a SpO2 sensor that’s used for sleep tracking, with a particular focus on the detection of breathing disturbances known as sleep apnoea. Unlike the Sleep Analyzer, full sleep apnea tracking isn’t available right now – it’s pending certification – but in the meantime, there’s a more vague ‘breathing disturbances’ measure to give you a rough indicator. Beyond apnoea, the ScanWatch measures everything you’d expect, including sleep duration, depth, interruptions, regularity, and sleeping heart rate, giving you an overall sleep score out of 100 for every night, and it’ll track your movement and exercise all day long too.
Ability to play your own music Comfortable for side-sleepers Plenty of sounds in-app
Hit-and-miss sleep tracking Case doesn't charge the earbuds
It’s not the first to offer that experience, but where it separates itself from the likes of the Amazfit ZenBuds and Bose SleepBuds II is the ability to play your own music in addition to the huge library of sounds on offer from the Kokoon app. In the world of sleep-focused earbuds, that’s a huge deal. They’re also impressively comfortable, with a slimline design and squidgy silicone build making them comfy even for side sleepers. The only real downside is that the sleep tracking is hit-and-miss, with some sleep sessions simply not recorded (or not synced) with the Kokoon app – though the company says it’s working on a fix, so it shouldn’t be an issue soon.
Premium design Full smartwatch experience Provides insights into sleep trends
Needs charging every day No recommendations on how to improve sleep
This ties in with all the other health and fitness data collected by your Apple Watch and is presented well in the Health app for iPhone. It’ll alert you to trends, both good and bad, like an increased breathing rate or low body temperature over longer periods, helping you spot any potential issues that need checking out. Of course, with one-day battery life, you’ll have to remember to charge the Apple Watch just before bed, but the watch will (handily enough) remind you of this around an hour before you go to sleep.
Great sleep tracking Excellent smartwatch features Monitors blood oxygen during sleep
Expensive No third-party apps Previously available features are gone
Like all Fitbits, it also is a great sleep tracker and boasts an auto-sleep mode that’ll automatically recognise when you’re asleep – no need to set it to a ‘sleep’ mode like with other trackers. It measures the duration of sleep, and splits this into three Sleep Stages: Light sleep, Deep sleep, and REM sleep. Alongside Restoration (which measures your sleeping heart rate vs your daytime resting heart rate), it gives you a nightly Sleep Score out of 100, and detailed data on how to improve the quality of your sleep. As with the top-end Fitbit Sense, the Versa 4 also measures your SpO2 blood oxygen saturation. Nighttime SpO2 is usually lower than daytime SpO2 because your breathing rate is, on average, slower during sleep. And, of course, you get all the fitness measurements (heart rate, cardio scores, and exercise modes), and smartwatch features (on-wrist phone calls, message notifications) though with the notable omissions of Google Assistant and music control compared to the Versa 3.
Affordable In-depth sleep tracking Discreet design
No blood oxygen monitoring Monochrome display
In terms of sleep tracking, it offers stats including sleep duration, quality of sleep (including Light, Deep and REM sleep measurements) and score, just like the Fitbit Versa 4. The Inspire 3 doesn’t GPS for general fitness tracking, but it’s a great affordable activity tracker that also offers all the sleep-quality tracking you need.
Very affordable Insightful sleep tracking Large OLED display
No third-party app integration
If you’re on the market for a cheap sleep tracker that’ll track sleep quality and length, you can’t go wrong with the Mi Band 7.
Sleek design In-depth sleep tracking with useful tips Analyses breathing
Companion app needs work No third-party app integration No NFC
The Watch Fit 2 will automatically detect when you fall asleep and, the following morning, provides a breakdown of your light sleep, deep sleep, and REM, as well as analysis on your breathing via the SpO2 sensor. It also has a database of over 200 tips on how to improve your sleep based on your results. It’s relatively inexpensive, offers multi-day battery life and the 1.4in rectangular OLED display is a nice touch too.
Classic wristwatch design 25-day battery life Detailed sleep tracking
No third-party app support Limited notification support
It’s capable of tracking over 30 activities, from running to swimming and even yoga or ping pong (not to mention sleeping, of course), and the 25-day battery life means you never need to worry about charging it. Couple that with an app that provides meaningful insight into the data collected by the smartwatch, and you’ve got the perfect fitness companion.
Comfortable low-profile design Great accompanying app Decent sound quality
Not suitable for side-sleepers
The earcups are huge, reaching beyond your ears and resting on your skull for extra comfort, and the soft inner earcups perfect the experience with a cool, soft touch. The accompanying Kokoon app for iOS and Android is well-built and easy to use, and offers a suite of soundscapes to use to fall asleep – some of which are even customisable. You’ll also find CBT-inspired breathing exercises and multi-day programs to help improve the quality of your sleep, along with a breakdown of your previous night’s sleep. The issue is that it’s just not comfortable for side-sleepers – the plastic swivel joints dig into the side of your head, causing enough discomfort to distract you from the main aim; getting to sleep. Still, if you’re looking for a way to drift off to sleep using headphones and want to go for a more recognisable brand, the SleepBuds II are a good option – although they’re not without their flaws. For that portion of the market, there are other options available; the Withings Sleep Analyzer is essentially a strip of sensors that are laid on your bed under your mattress, and tracks your sleep as you lay on it. Most sleep trackers are fairly understated in design and are covered in a soft material as to not cause skin irritation over long periods, although it may be worth reading user reviews of the tracker you want before buying in case of any comfort issues. As mentioned above, you don’t have to wear all sleep trackers, although you’ll more than likely have to pay more money for a bed monitor when compared to its wearable counterpart. If you do opt for a wearable, be conscious of displays – while having a display is helpful for operation, screens can get snagged when moving your arms during your sleep, which can wake you up. Not ideal. There’s also a choice between types of battery as rechargeable batteries are more convenient but don’t last as long, while some sleep trackers boast a six-month battery life due to the use of a traditional watch battery. Of course, it’s worth noting that once it runs out, you’ll have to hunt down a replacement watch battery yourself. You can find trackers that’ll track your resting heart rate throughout the night, some that’ll track the quality of the air and ambient noise, and some that’ll even notify you if you’ve been snoring during the night. This will help you determine if there’s an environmental factor affecting your sleep. What you need to ask yourself is whether you really need the advanced functionality, as there’s a direct relationship between the number of tracking features offered and the price tag. It’s also worth mentioning that it’s usually cheaper trackers that have bad-quality apps, as it’s likely that the company has skimped on the development of the app and focused on making the hardware as cheap as possible. If you’re an iOS user, look out for trackers that integrate with Apple’s Health app for a better overall look at your personal health (when combined with fitness tracking, eating habits, etc). Lewis Painter is a Senior Staff Writer at Tech Advisor. Our resident Apple expert, Lewis covers everything from iPhone to AirPods, plus a range of smartphones, tablets, laptops and gaming hardware. You’ll also find him on the Tech Advisor YouTube channel.
